Why a Cross Reference — and Its Limits
Engineers design with one brand's part number; procurement then carries the second-source risk. A good cross reference shortens that path, but a part number alone never guarantees equivalent performance: µ′ curves, losses, thickness tolerance, and the adhesive system all matter. So this table gives you a starting grade, and our sample-verification protocol below does the proving.
The matching rule. Same µ′ at the working frequency (for NFC, 13.56 MHz), compatible thickness, then sample verification on your own fixture. “Grade matching + sample verification” is our standard answer — because permeability curves, not part numbers, decide performance.
NFC Ferrite Sheets @ 13.56 MHz: the Table
| Manufacturer | Part number | Nominal µ′ @ 13.56 MHz | XAK starting grade | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Laird | MSLL100 | ≈ 100 | XAK-NFC 100 | Public datasheet value — re-confirm at PO |
| Laird | MHLL130 | ≈ 130 | XAK-NFC 130 | Public datasheet value — re-confirm at PO |
| Laird | MULL150 | ≈ 150 | XAK-NFC 150 | Public datasheet value — re-confirm at PO |
| Maruwa | FSF131 | ≈ 130 (per series naming) | XAK-NFC 130 | Confirm against manufacturer datasheet |
| Maruwa | FSF151 | ≈ 150 (per series naming) | XAK-NFC 150 | Confirm against manufacturer datasheet |
| TDK | IBQ15 (Flexield) | 150-class (per series naming) | XAK-NFC 150 | Confirm against manufacturer datasheet |
| Kitagawa | FFSX series | Grade-dependent | Match by µ′ at 13.56 MHz | Series, not a single grade — confirm per suffix |
| XAK | XAK-NFC 20 / 50 / 100 / 130 / 150 | 20 / 50 / 100 / 130 / 150 (±20%) | — | Our grades; curves measured at 13.56 MHz |
Values for competitor parts are nominal µ′ figures as commonly published for these series; where we have not verified the current datasheet we mark the cell instead of guessing. XAK-NFC grades are measured at 13.56 MHz with ±20% tolerance. Thickness options are per drawing — send us your outline and we confirm the available window.
Not NFC? Two Related Crosses
EMI absorber sheets: 3M AB5000HF series → XAK S-A
3M's AB5000HF series (AB5010HF, AB5020HF, …) are absorber sheets, not NFC ferrite — they dissipate EMI energy across roughly 10 MHz–18 GHz instead of guiding NFC flux. If your BOM line is an AB5000HF part, the XAK counterpart is the S-A absorber sheet series (µ′ 20–300 @ 1 MHz, 0.03–2 mm). Match by µ′/µ″ at your noise frequency, not by part number.
Nanocrystalline sheets: Laird nano / TDK Flexield IFQ → XAK F-N
For wireless-charging stacks, Laird's nanocrystalline sheet line and TDK's Flexield IFQ series sit in the same material class as our F-N nanocrystalline sheet (µ′ ≥ 13,000 @ 100 kHz, Bs 1.25 T, 0.06–0.4 mm flexible ribbon). These are matched by Bs, thickness and loss at the charging frequency — see the Qi2 MPP guide for how 360 kHz changes the spec.
The Verification Protocol Before You Switch
- 1. Match by curve. Compare µ′/µ″ at your working frequency from both datasheets — not the part-number headline, not a single-frequency marketing number.
- 2. Match geometry. Same thickness within tolerance, same outline, same adhesive position. Cut-edge quality changes Q more than most teams expect.
- 3. Sample on your fixture. We cut samples to your drawing; you measure read range (NFC), coupling or temp rise (WPT) on your own reader/antenna or coil.
- 4. Pilot the cut. Run a small pilot lot before releasing the second source to production. One sample round closes most NFC crosses.
We supply validation samples against this protocol at no charge for standard grades — the goal is that your verification costs less than the risk it removes.